---
title: How to choose a commercial broker: models, pay and tools | a guide by Delegance
description: What broker, agency, platform and embedded API mean, how each is paid, what the law asks of broker fees, and how to judge AI claims.
---

Published by Delegance Brokerage, a licensed commercial insurance broker and one of the brokers compared here. Delegance earns a flat, disclosed fee when you buy through it.

# How to choose a commercial broker: models, pay and tools

Two firms can sell you the same policy from the same carrier and still be paid differently and give you different tools. Start with the model.

## Four models you will see

- **Brokerage.** Licensed to place coverage for you with many carriers. Paid by commission from the carrier, a fee from you, or both.
- **Digital agency.** A licensed agency that sells mostly online, often small policies a business can buy in minutes.
- **Risk management platform.** A broker that adds software and specialists, such as attorneys or loss control, around the placement.
- **Embedded API.** A broker that sells through other software, such as a payroll or banking app, as well as directly.

## How brokers are paid

Most brokers earn a commission, a percentage of the premium the carrier pays them. Some also earn contingent commissions tied to a carrier's results, or charge you a fee. A compensation disclosure lists the types; it rarely lists the rate. Ask for the rate on your own policies.

State law sets rules for fees. In New York a broker may charge a fee only under a written memorandum signed by the client ([DFS Circular Letter 9 (2006) on Insurance Law 2119](https://www.dfs.ny.gov/industry_guidance/circular_letters/cl2006_09)). Rules differ in other states; ask the broker which apply to you.

## How to judge an AI claim

1. Ask whether the AI works for the broker's staff or for you. Both can be useful; only the second changes what you can do at 2 a.m.
2. Ask whether your own tools can connect. An MCP server, a public API or a ChatGPT or Claude app means they can.
3. Ask what still needs a person, and how fast that person answers.

## Questions to ask any broker

- What are you: broker, agency, platform or API?
- What will you earn on my policies, in percent or dollars?
- Which carriers appoint you directly?
- What can I do myself, and through which tools?

## How Delegance answers these questions

- **How the broker is paid.** A flat, disclosed 5% fee in place of the 15 to 25% commission a traditional broker typically takes. You see the rate before you buy.
- **Cost or savings claim.** Total insurance expense typically falls 10 to 20% on a placement, with the same admitted carriers. Your result depends on your risk, your carriers and your current program.
- **Quotes and buying online.** Free quotes with no signup through the portal, the CLI or the MCP server; instant online quotes for eligible small business classes; multi-carrier quotes typically within 24 hours.
- **Certificate of insurance.** Certificates of insurance in about 60 seconds, self-serve, from the portal, ChatGPT, Claude, Slack, email or phone.
- **Licensing.** Licensed in all 50 states and DC, agency NPN 21282686. Appointed directly by 25 carriers, including Chubb, Travelers and The Hartford.

Compare it with six other tech-enabled brokers on the [comparison table](/).

[Get a free Delegance quote](https://portal.delegancebrokerage.com/onboarding/company?ref=insurancebrokercompare.com&utm_source=comparison_site&utm_medium=web&utm_content=guide) Delegance publishes this site and earns a flat, disclosed fee if you buy through it.

---

Published by Delegance Brokerage, a licensed commercial insurance broker and one of the brokers compared here. Delegance earns a flat, disclosed fee when you buy through it. This site is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any other company named on it. Company names belong to their owners and appear in plain text only.

Every statement about another broker links to that broker's own page and shows the date we read it. See [sources and method](/sources). To correct a fact, write to [alex@delegancebrokerage.com](mailto:alex@delegancebrokerage.com).

Insurance is placed by Delegance LLC dba Delegance Brokerage, NPN 21282686, 234 10th Ave, New York, NY 10011. Nothing here is an offer of insurance; coverage is subject to underwriting and policy terms. Savings figures are typical results, not a promise.
